Periodic table why is it arranged

ACS values your privacy. We use the information you provide to make your reading experience better, and we will never sell your data to third party members. Log in here. Already an ACS Member? Choose the membership that is right for you. Discount will be applied automatically at checkout. Your account has been created successfully, and a confirmation email is on the way. And scientists are still debating its optimum configuration. Some believe chemical properties should dictate how the elements line up on the periodic table.

Others think a more fundamental principle is needed, like electronic configuration or simply atomic number. Partisans are clashing over which elements belong in group 3, where helium should go, and how many columns the periodic table should have. They follow a long line of chemists and physicists who have worked and reworked the elements into a semblance of order.

Gordin, a Princeton University historian who has written about Mendeleev, Julius Lothar Meyer, and other creators of early periodic tables. That might be hard to imagine for those of us used to seeing the familiar shape of the table on our coffee mug or shower curtain. Each column of elements shared properties. Contact us to opt out anytime. Mendeleev arranged the elements in order of increasing weight and broke them into rows such that elements in each column shared valence, the number of other atoms they combined with, as well as other properties.

Lothar Meyer was independently working on an almost identical table, but Mendeleev beat him to publication by a few months and secured his place in history. Mendeleev ostensibly organized his table by increasing atomic weight, but he gave chemical properties a deciding vote. For example, tellurium is slightly heavier than iodine, but Mendeleev put tellurium first because it has the same valence as oxygen, sulfur, and other elements in its group.

Tables have retained that ordering. Along with protons came the discovery of electrons and the quantum-mechanical idea of atomic orbitals. These findings provided a whole new kind of logic for the periodic system. The Madelung rule, or aufbau principle, that dictates that electrons fill the 1s orbital first and then the 2s and the 2p and so on, further explained how the elements were ordered.

Related: Adventures with the periodic table. Seaborg drew in the s. Seaborg moved the f-block elements—also called the lanthanide and actinide series—out of the main table to leave them floating below.

This decision is generally understood as a concession to convenience; if those elements were in line with the others, the table would be too wide to fit on a standard sheet of paper or the type would be too small to read. Seaborg included 15 elements in his f-block. But many tables—including the table on the website of the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry IUPAC , which has the last word on naming elements and molecules—share this feature.

No one disputes scandium and yttrium. But which elements come below those two? Lanthanum and actinium? Or lutetium and lawrencium? Some avoid the group 3 question and use a element f-block. Others put La and Ac in group 3, and still others have Lu and Lr, with the remainder of the f-block floating below.

IUPAC has convened a working group to make a definitive recommendation one way or the other. Philip Ball, a science writer and member of the working group, says the debate comes down to a fundamental question of whether physics or chemistry shapes the table. On the side of chemical behavior is Guillermo Restrepo, a mathematical chemist at the Max Planck Institute for Mathematics in the Sciences. Restrepo takes a historical view of how the table should be organized. Restrepo and colleagues analyzed some 4, binary compounds containing 94 elements to determine how chemical reactions inform the periodic system MATCH Commun.

The molecules could consist of more than one atom but only two elements. The researchers created a map that groups elements near those that form similar compounds. For example, fluorine, chlorine, and the other halogens sit next to each other because they all bind to similar elements. Restrepo says this similarity landscape shows that lanthanum is more similar to scandium and yttrium than lutetium is, so it should be in group 3.

While there are tens of thousands of compounds one can use to study the similarities of Sc, Y, La, and Lu, Ac provides only about 70 data points, and Lr, fewer than 40, according to Restrepo. He believes Sc, Y, Lu, and Lr should be the group 3 elements. Scerri thinks a focus on chemical or physical properties is misguided.

Not that electronic configuration is perfect either, as Scerri will tell you. Petersburg, Russia. Since there were no modern organic chemistry textbooks in Russian at that time, Mendeleev decided to write one, and simultaneously tackle the problem of the disordered elements. Putting the elements in any kind of order would prove quite difficult. At this time, less than half of the elements were known, and some of these had been given wrong data. It was like working on a really difficult jigsaw puzzle with only half of the pieces and with some of the pieces misshapen.

Mendeleev ultimately wrote the definitive chemistry textbook of his time, titled "Principles of Chemistry" two volumes, — , according to Khan Academy. As he was working on it, he came upon a significant discovery that would contribute greatly to the development of the current periodic table.

After writing the properties of the elements on cards, he began ordering them by increasing atomic weight, according to the Royal Society of Chemistry. This is when he noticed certain types of elements regularly appearing.

After intensely working on this "puzzle" for three days, Mendeleev said that he had a dream in which all of the elements fell into place as required.

When he woke up, he immediately wrote them down on a piece of paper — only in one place did a correction seem necessary, he later said. Develop and improve products. List of Partners vendors. Share Flipboard Email. Anne Marie Helmenstine, Ph. Chemistry Expert. Helmenstine holds a Ph.

She has taught science courses at the high school, college, and graduate levels. Facebook Facebook Twitter Twitter. Updated October 30, Featured Video. Cite this Article Format. What is the ideal gas law constant? How do you calculate the ideal gas law constant? How do you find density in the ideal gas law? Does ideal gas law apply to liquids?

Impact of this question views around the world.